This research-led Tide vs Mettle comparison uses official provider and FSCS information checked on 8 November 2026. It does not claim long-term account use, support testing or first-hand payment experience.
Our verdict
For capability and growth
Tide wins Tide vs Mettle overall because fewer businesses will outgrow its access, payment and product model. The Free plan can start at £0, while Smart, Pro and Max provide a clearer route to higher allowances, team access and additional accounts. Tide also sends international payments, whereas Mettle currently receives supported overseas payments but cannot send them.
Mettle is the sharper choice for a narrow but important audience. Its core account has no maintenance fee, UK transactions do not carry routine transfer charges, invoicing and tax tools are included, and qualifying customers can receive FreeAgent without a separate subscription by making at least one qualifying Mettle transaction each month. That can outweigh small banking-fee differences.
At a glance
Quick decision support

Choose Tide if...

Choose Mettle if...
Current offers
Tide and Mettle offers
Offers are secondary to the editorial verdict. Confirm live terms before applying.

Up to £200 with STARTUP200 in two conditional stages. Eligibility and qualifying-transaction rules apply.
Code

Eligibility, qualifying actions, deadlines and payment timing are controlled by the live referral terms and can change.
Code
Side by side
Tide vs Mettle comparison table
Scroll sideways to compare both providers
| Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Broader functionality, international capability and growth | Solo operators who value FreeAgent |
| Monthly fee | £0, £12.49, £27.49 or £69.99 | £0; Mettle+ £4 |
| UK transfers | 5 included on Free, then normally 20p; larger allowances on paid plans | No routine UK transfer fee published |
| Eligibility | UK sole traders and eligible companies | Sole traders and Ltd companies with up to two owners; one owner access |
| Account structure | ClearBank-powered current account | NatWest bank account trading as Mettle |
| Cash | Post Office and PayPoint; variable fees | Post Office, £2.75 per deposit |
| Cheques | Digital cheque deposit for eligible accounts; fee applies | Not supported |
| International | Outbound, inbound and SWIFT routes supported | Inbound in 30 currencies; no outbound |
| Team access | Tiered access, expense cards and additional accounts | Only one owner can access |
| Invoicing | Included in wider toolkit | Included; Mettle+ adds quotes and templates |
| Accounting | Built-in accounting and MTD ecosystem | FreeAgent included subject to monthly qualifying transaction |
| Integrations | Supported software connections, some plan-dependent | FreeAgent, Xero and QuickBooks |
| Savings | Instant Saver, plan-based variable rates | One Savings Pot at 0.95% AER variable currently |
| Borrowing | Tide credit and partner finance | Not a core Mettle account feature |
| Support | 24/7 in-app; enhanced paid-tier service | Published staffed hours, not 24/7 live chat |
| Current offer | Up to £200, conditional | £50 referral offer with QPBB6, subject to live terms |
| Overall verdict | Overall winner: more adaptable | Exceptional focused value for FreeAgent users |
Category wins
Where each provider wins

Where Tide wins

Where Mettle wins
Illustrative fees
Illustrative fee patterns
These examples use only fees stated in this comparison. Actual costs depend on the account plan, transaction volume and usage, so confirm live pricing before applying. They are illustrations, not quotes or guaranteed charges.
Tide
Mettle
Mettle usually cleaner for simple UK transfer patterns
Tide
Mettle
Model actual deposit size and frequency before choosing
Tide
Mettle
Compare workflow value, not adjacent price points
Tide vs Mettle provider overview
Tide wraps a ClearBank-powered current account in a broader business-finance platform. Its product range covers invoicing, accounting, MTD, payment collection, savings, credit and card acceptance. Mettle is a NatWest business bank account designed around self-employed people and small companies, with unusually strong bookkeeping value through FreeAgent.
The central Tide vs Mettle decision is therefore not which free account has more feature ticks. It is whether Mettle's included accounting software and simple UK banking match the operating model, or whether Tide's broader access and payments will prevent a later migration.
Editor's note: read the full Tide review and Mettle review for the complete provider analysis.
Tide vs Mettle eligibility and ownership
Tide accepts UK sole traders and eligible registered companies, subject to its current activity, ownership and identity checks. It offers a more scalable access model through paid tiers and additional business current accounts.
Mettle is specifically for sole traders and limited companies with up to two owners. Only one owner can access the account, and only one Mettle account can be opened per person. The business must be registered and trading in the UK, users need UK residence and a UK phone number, and the account requires a compatible iOS or Android device. Published balances can reach £1 million, but eligibility and sector exclusions remain.
Mettle's two-owner eligibility is not the same as two-owner operation. If both directors need to log in, approve payments or manage cards, choose Tide or another team account.
Tide vs Mettle fees and UK banking
Mettle has the cleaner headline. There is no monthly account-maintenance fee and its fee document does not list a routine charge for ordinary UK transfers. Mettle+ is optional at £4 a month and adds quotes, bespoke messaging templates and quote-to-invoice workflows.
Tide Free has no monthly subscription but includes five bank transfers per month before a normal 20p charge. Smart costs £12.49 and includes 30; Pro at £27.49 and Max at £69.99 currently include unlimited bank transfers. Tide's paid tiers only win on value when their wider allowances, team tools or other services are used.
For a consultant receiving bank transfers and paying a few UK expenses, Mettle can be genuinely low cost. For a business needing more accounts, users, cards, payments or finance, Tide's higher total cost may buy capabilities Mettle does not provide.
Tide vs Mettle cash, cheques and cards
Mettle accepts Post Office cash deposits for £2.75 each. Current guidance allows £10 to £500 per deposit, £500 per day and £23,000 per year. It does not accept cheques. This rules it out for cheque-reliant businesses and limits its suitability for high-cash turnover.
Tide accepts cash at Post Offices and PayPoint. Post Office deposits cost £2.50 up to £500; above that threshold current pricing is 0.99% on Free and 0.5% on paid plans. PayPoint costs 3%. Published limits apply. Tide also supports digital cheque deposits for eligible accounts, with a fee.
Both provide a business debit card and mobile controls. Tide has the better route to team and expense cards. Mettle remains designed around one account user.
Tide vs Mettle international payments
International capability creates the clearest Tide vs Mettle split. Tide supports international bank transfers and SWIFT. Free charges a 2.75% Tide fee on foreign-currency card payments and specified overseas GBP use; paid plans currently show 0% Tide FX fee for international card payments, although transfer and third-party fees can remain.
Mettle now receives payments in 30 currencies and converts them to GBP. Payments over £10 incur £4, plus 1.5% where currency conversion is required. Below £10 there is no fixed charge, although the 1.5% conversion fee applies where relevant. Mettle does not currently send international payments.
A freelancer paid by an overseas client may be able to use Mettle, but a business paying overseas suppliers cannot rely on it as the sole operational account.
Tide vs Mettle invoicing, accounting, FreeAgent and tax
Mettle wins a specific accounting use case. Eligible customers can receive FreeAgent included, provided they make at least one qualifying transaction from the Mettle account each month. Transfers between Mettle Pots do not satisfy the condition, and paid FreeAgent add-ons can still cost extra. Mettle states this can save at least £150 a year based on FreeAgent's lowest tariff.
FreeAgent can handle bank feeds, bookkeeping, invoices, cash flow and tax workflows. Mettle also includes invoicing, receipt capture, categorisation, Tax Pots and payment matching. Mettle+ improves the pre-invoice sales workflow.
Tide offers the broader native environment: invoicing, transaction categorisation, built-in accounting, HMRC-recognised MTD tools, tax features and connections to external software. Some services and connectors have separate pricing or plan requirements.
Choose Mettle when FreeAgent is the accounting system you genuinely want. Choose Tide when you want accounting closer to a wider payment and finance platform, or your accountant prefers another supported workflow.
Tide vs Mettle app, support, savings and borrowing
Both are app-led, but Mettle requires a compatible mobile device to open and manage the account. Tide also offers web tools within its broader platform. No unsupported first-hand app ranking is used here.
Tide advertises 24/7 in-app support. Mettle offers in-app chat, email and telephone support from 8am to 8pm Monday to Friday and 9am to 5pm on weekends and bank holidays. Messages can be left outside those hours, but it is not a 24/7 live-chat service.
Mettle's one Savings Pot currently pays 0.95% AER variable on balances from £10 and can hold up to £1 million, under its terms. Tide Instant Saver rates vary by account plan. Tide also has a stronger borrowing proposition through credit products and partner finance. All lending is separately assessed.
Tide vs Mettle FSCS and provider structure
Both state that eligible deposits are FSCS protected up to £120,000. The route differs. Tide's business current account is powered by ClearBank. Mettle is provided by National Westminster Bank plc trading as Mettle.
FSCS protection is subject to depositor eligibility and aggregation. If you already hold money with ClearBank, NatWest or a banking group operating under the relevant licence, use the FSCS checker and read the account information before assuming each brand creates a separate £120,000 allowance. Historic Mettle e-money products were not the same protected bank account, so existing customers should confirm their documentation.
Suitability
Tide vs Mettle by business type
Sole trader using FreeAgent
MettleConditional FreeAgent inclusion can remove a subscription See sole trader bank accounts.
Freelancer paid by UK transfer
MettleNo maintenance fee and focused bookkeeping See freelancer bank accounts.
Limited company with two active directors
TideMettle allows only one owner to access the account See limited company bank accounts.
Startup expecting rapid operational growth
TideMore plans, accounts, team tools and finance routes See startup business bank accounts.
Business receiving overseas client payments only
DependsMettle can receive 30 currencies; compare its fixed and conversion fees with Tide
Business sending overseas payments
TideMettle cannot send them
Cash taker
DependsModel Tide route-based charges against Mettle's £2.75 deposits and limits
Cheque recipient
TideMettle does not accept cheques
Business prioritising all-in-one admin
TideWider business-finance ecosystem
Business prioritising included full accounting software
MettleFreeAgent is the differentiator
Tide vs Mettle decision scenarios
Scenario 1: a self-employed consultant with ten UK transactions a month. Mettle is likely to provide the cleaner low-cost setup if the consultant wants FreeAgent. There is no maintenance fee, routine UK transfers are not separately priced in the fee document, and one qualifying account transaction each month can preserve FreeAgent inclusion. Tide Free would remain viable, but payments beyond its five-transfer allowance and any optional services should be included in the calculation.
Scenario 2: a two-director agency hiring its first employee. Tide is the safer forward-looking choice. Mettle may accept a company with two owners, but only one can operate the account. That restriction can frustrate holiday cover, payment approvals and basic financial governance. Tide's paid tiers create clearer options for access, cards, budgets and additional accounts.
Scenario 3: a trades business taking £1,500 cash each month. Neither provider should be chosen from the monthly fee alone. The owner should divide expected deposits by route and value, apply Tide's Post Office or PayPoint pricing, and compare the result with Mettle's £2.75 charge and deposit limits. Cheque receipts would independently favour Tide.
Scenario 4: a designer receiving US client payments and paying an overseas contractor. Mettle can receive a supported currency, apply its fixed and conversion charges, and credit GBP. It cannot make the contractor payment. Tide therefore provides the more complete operating account, although a specialist multi-currency provider may quote more competitively.
These scenarios show why Tide vs Mettle cannot be reduced to “free versus free”. The decisive cost may be accounting software, cash handling, a second user or an otherwise impossible payment.
Tide vs Mettle limitations
Tide can become expensive or complex when transaction fees, cash, FX, add-ons and a paid plan accumulate. Its wide product set also means “included with Tide” must be distinguished from a separately priced or eligibility-dependent product.
Mettle's restrictions are structural: one owner access, one account per person, no cheques and no outbound international payments. Those limits matter more than a missing convenience feature because they can force a second account or later switch.
Tide vs Mettle opening and switching considerations
Both applications are digital and subject to identity, business and compliance checks. Mettle requires a compatible phone. Have ID, UK contact details, business-address and activity information, and Companies House and ownership data ready.
Do not assume a quick form means guaranteed immediate approval. Before moving an existing account, map Direct Debits, incoming payments, saved payees, accounting feeds and card-dependent subscriptions. Tide advertises CASS for eligible switches. For Mettle, confirm the current switching route before promising an automated full switch.
Tide vs Mettle: which should you choose?
Choose Tide if international payments, multiple users, additional accounts, credit or a wider suite of business services is important now or likely soon. It is our overall Tide vs Mettle winner because it serves more operating models and has fewer growth blockers.
Choose Mettle if the business is deliberately simple: one operator, mainly UK payments, limited cash, no cheques, no outbound overseas transfers, and a real need for FreeAgent. In that scenario Mettle may deliver the best total value of the three providers in this batch.
The correct Tide vs Mettle decision should survive the expiry of any cashback. Compare the next two years of workflow and fees, not only the first month.
Alternatives
Other business accounts to consider
Monzo Business
Better for free UK transfers, cheque handling, 24/7 support and a direct UK bank relationship. Read the Monzo Business review, or see the Monzo vs Mettle comparison and the Tide vs Monzo comparison.
ANNA Money
Relevant when invoicing and admin automation lead the decision.
Revolut Business
Relevant for multi-currency operations and team controls.
Offers
Tide and Mettle offer details
Tide offer details
Tide's tracked STARTUP200 route offers up to £200 in two stages. £75 requires at least £100 of qualifying Tide card spend within 30 days. The further £125 requires at least £5,000 to reach Tide Instant Saver within 7 days of opening and remain there for 30 days. The conditions and time windows must stay next to the amount wherever displayed.
Mettle offer details
Mettle offers £50 cashback using code QPBB6, confirmed by the publisher. Eligibility, qualifying actions, deadlines and payment timing are controlled by the live referral terms.
FAQs
Tide vs Mettle FAQs
Tide is better overall for capability and growth. Mettle can be better for a one-user, mainly UK business that values included FreeAgent.
Mettle has no maintenance fee and no routine UK transfer fee in its published fee document. Tide Free has no subscription but charges after five monthly transfers and has other usage fees. Total cost depends on activity.
Mettle is compelling for a sole trader using FreeAgent. Tide is better for international payments, payment collection, credit or a broader all-in-one toolkit.
Mettle suits a small company with up to two owners if only one needs access. Tide is better when several people need to operate the account or the company expects to scale.
Yes. Tide supports Post Office and PayPoint deposits with route and plan-based fees. Mettle charges £2.75 at the Post Office and applies published deposit limits.
Tide supports eligible digital cheque deposits for a fee. Mettle does not support cheques.
Mettle wins for businesses that want FreeAgent because it can be included after a qualifying monthly transaction. Tide has the broader built-in accounting and MTD ecosystem.
Both offer invoicing. Mettle includes invoice creation and matching, with Mettle+ adding quotes. Tide connects invoicing to a wider payment and accounting platform.
Tide. Mettle can receive 30 supported currencies and convert them to GBP but cannot send international payments.
Eligible deposits are stated as protected up to £120,000 with both. Tide uses ClearBank for the current account; Mettle is provided by NatWest. Scheme and aggregation rules apply.
No. Mettle accepts limited companies with up to two owners, but only one owner can access the account. Tide provides broader team access options.
Tide advertises 24/7 in-app support. Mettle publishes staffed support hours and is not a 24/7 live-chat service.
Mettle currently states 0.95% AER variable for its Savings Pot. Tide's Instant Saver rates vary by plan. Check live rates and access terms.
Tide has the stronger credit and partner-finance proposition. Mettle borrowing is not a core account feature.
Potentially, subject to approval. A second account may solve Mettle's outbound-payment or continuity limitations, but it adds reconciliation and administration.
Methodology
The verdict weights operating fit ahead of offers, with special attention to ownership access, international payments and the economic value of FreeAgent. Checked 8 November 2026. Explain the wider process via How We Compare.
Sources
Mettle
Last reviewed: