Research-led comparison checked against official information on 1 November 2026. No first-hand formation or support experience is claimed.
Our verdict
Tide wins for a simple eligible single-shareholder company
Tide wins Tide vs 1st Formations for the typical simple eligible company. Even after allowing £50 for a later online Confirmation Statement filing, Tide's £14.99 formation route has a lower combined statutory outlay than 1st Formations Digital at £102.99. It also integrates a free Tide business account and can unlock the separate conditional STARTUP200 promotion.
1st Formations is the stronger formation provider in breadth. It supports more company types, provides a specialist Online Company Manager, offers privacy and address packages, includes the first Confirmation Statement with Digital and gives founders several bank introductions rather than centring the journey on one account provider.
At a glance
Quick decision support

Choose Tide if...

Choose 1st Formations if...
Current offers
Tide and 1st Formations formation offers
Offers are secondary to the editorial verdict. Formation price is separate from banking promotions and recurring accounting services. Confirm live terms before applying.

£14.99 stand-alone formation through the tracked route. STARTUP200 can provide eligible new banking customers with £75 after qualifying card spending and a further £125 after the qualifying Instant Saver deposit and holding period. The maximum £200 is conditional and separate from incorporation.

Digital is currently £102.99 including the £100 Companies House fee. The separate All Inclusive with Accounting package is advertised at £1 because it starts a 12-month accounting subscription: first month free, then 11 payments from £49 + VAT, followed by rolling monthly service until cancelled.
Side by side
Tide vs 1st Formations comparison table
Scroll sideways to compare both providers
| Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Simple low-cost formation with Tide banking | Specialist support, privacy and wider structures |
| Standard price | £14.99 | Digital £102.99 |
| Companies House fee | Subsidised within price | £100 fee included |
| Identity verification | Included in formation journey | Free ACSP verification and personal code support |
| Documents | Certificate, Memorandum and Articles, share certificates and register | Digital incorporation documents and company register |
| First Confirmation Statement | Not stated as included | Filing included with Digital |
| Processing | Within one business day, subject to checks | Usually within 24 hours, subject to checks |
| Ownership/company types | Linked journeys state single-shareholder restriction | Limited by shares plus specialist, guarantee, LLP and non-resident routes |
| Address/privacy | Optional Tide Virtual Office | Privacy package and separate address services |
| Business banking | Tide account integrated | Choice of bank introductions; separate approvals |
| Ongoing admin | Tide Company Secretary available separately | Online Company Manager and wider compliance services |
| Accounting | Tide tools available separately | Full accounting route from £49 + VAT monthly after free first month |
| Entry promotion | STARTUP200 conditional banking cashback | £1 formation conditional on accounting subscription |
| Overall verdict | Overall winner for a simple eligible founder | Better specialist and complex-needs provider |
Category wins
Where each provider wins

Where Tide wins

Where 1st Formations wins
Comparing the real first-year cost
Tide's £14.99 route does not state that the first Confirmation Statement is included. Companies House currently charges £50 for an online Confirmation Statement within the relevant annual fee period. A simple Tide company paying that directly would therefore face £64.99 across incorporation and its first statement, before optional services.
1st Formations Digital costs £102.99 and includes both the £100 incorporation fee and filing of the first Confirmation Statement. Its effective formation-agent premium over the statutory incorporation fee is only £2.99, while the included statement filing can be commercially meaningful.
That does not make Digital cheaper in cash terms. It makes the service comparison more balanced than £14.99 versus £102.99 initially suggests. Founders should also price any registered-office, mail, secretarial, accounting or same-day add-ons and record renewal dates.
The £1 routes are not equivalent
Both brands advertise a £1 formation route, but neither should be compared as a £1 stand-alone formation.
Tide's £1 option requires its Company Secretary subscription, currently £12.50 + VAT per month. 1st Formations' £1 All Inclusive with Accounting route requires a full accounting subscription. The first month is free, followed by 11 payments from £49 + VAT, after which the service rolls monthly.
The right question is whether the recurring service is needed and competitively priced. Taking a subscription solely to reduce the formation payment can create a much higher total cost.
Eligibility, structure and non-residents
Tide's streamlined route is designed for a UK-based business and its linked journeys state a single-shareholder restriction. It is not the natural choice for several shareholders, bespoke Articles or a non-resident package.
1st Formations offers limited-by-shares, limited-by-guarantee, LLP and non-resident propositions. Complex share rights, investment documents and tax planning can still require a solicitor, accountant or tax adviser, but the package range provides a broader starting point.
Tide vs 1st Formations therefore changes winner quickly when the company is outside Tide's standard shape. 1st Formations wins by default if Tide cannot support the intended structure.
Privacy and registered-office services
A registered office appears on the public register, so founders using a home address should make a deliberate privacy decision. Tide offers a separate Virtual Office Address product. Confirm its current location, mail handling, renewal price and eligibility before buying.
1st Formations' Privacy package currently costs £117.99 including the Companies House fee and adds registered-office and service-address protection. It also offers business-address and mail services. Check exactly which addresses cover the company, directors and ordinary commercial post.
1st Formations wins this category because address services are central to its package structure. Tide can still be competitive if its Virtual Office happens to match the founder's needs and price.
Banking choice
Tide forms the company around a Tide account application. That is efficient when Tide is already the intended bank. The account can support invoicing, accounting, payments, savings and finance as the company develops.
1st Formations introduces customers to a selection of bank providers. Its current site advertises multiple options, including digital and high-street accounts. Every account has separate eligibility and approval, and an introduction is not a guarantee.
Choose flexibility if you have not decided on a bank. Choose Tide if consolidating the formation and finance platform is genuinely useful.
Support and account management
1st Formations publishes weekday customer-service hours and specialist contact routes. Its free Online Company Manager can store documents, show company details and support later administration. Tide's formation is supported within its broader digital platform and Company Secretary can provide ongoing filing assistance when subscribed.
The specialist model is better for founders who want formation-specific help. The integrated Tide model is better for owners who want fewer platforms and are comfortable with a standardised journey.
Formation journey and checkout risks
Prepare the company name, registered office, registered email, director and shareholder details, PSC information, SIC code and share allocation before starting. Identity verification should be completed using accurate names and current address evidence. Incomplete or inconsistent information can delay either route.
Tide's streamlined journey reduces choice, which is helpful for a simple company but unsuitable when the legal structure needs thought. 1st Formations presents more packages and add-ons, which improves flexibility but creates a longer buying decision. Do not purchase address, same-day, document or compliance extras simply because they appear during checkout.
Read the final order summary before payment. Identify which items are one-off, which renew annually, which are quoted plus VAT and which depend on a separate bank or accounting agreement. Save a copy of the package description and cancellation terms.
Illustrative scenarios
Illustrative first-year cost scenarios
Published figures are used for comparison, not as personalised quotes.
Tide formation plus a later £50 online Confirmation Statement would currently total £64.99 before banking or optional services. Digital costs £102.99 and includes filing that first statement. Tide remains cheaper, while Digital removes a task and adds formation-specialist support.
Tide's £14.99 must be combined with the live Virtual Office cost. 1st Formations Privacy currently costs £117.99 including the statutory fee and address services. Compare mail handling, director service-address protection and renewal rather than adding only the headline prices.
The 1st Formations £1 route may be competitive if its service scope and Xero inclusion replace an accountant the business would otherwise buy. At the lowest advertised accounting rate, 11 payments of £49 + VAT follow the free first month. Tide should be compared with the full external accounting cost, not with £1.
Tide's mainstream route is unlikely to be the appropriate comparator. The dedicated 1st Formations package, address services, banking introductions and any tax advice become the relevant cost stack.
Responsibilities after formation
The chosen provider does not become responsible for every director duty. Preserve company documents, maintain statutory registers where required, monitor the Confirmation Statement date and organise annual accounts and Corporation Tax work. Record the start of trading and assess PAYE and VAT obligations.
If 1st Formations files the first Confirmation Statement, confirm what happens in the second year. If Tide Company Secretary is not purchased, decide who will manage changes and deadlines. A free bank account or company-management portal is useful infrastructure, but directors remain responsible for accurate and timely information.
Suitability
Which is better by founder type?
| Founder need | Better fit | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Solo UK owner-director | Tide | Lowest simple formation cost |
| Several shareholders | 1st Formations | Broader structural support |
| Non-UK resident | 1st Formations | Dedicated non-resident package |
| Home-address privacy | 1st Formations | Privacy package is central and clear |
| Tide banking user | Tide | Integrated onboarding |
| Undecided on bank | 1st Formations | Multiple introductions |
| Wants full accountant | Depends | Compare 1st accounting scope with independent alternatives |
| Bespoke Articles/investment | Professional advice | Neither standard package should replace legal advice |
Limitations and switching considerations
Tide may be too narrow for the intended ownership. 1st Formations can become expensive when optional and renewing services accumulate. Review every checkout line, VAT treatment, annual renewal and cancellation term.
If you form through one provider and bank elsewhere, preserve incorporation documents, verification codes, service agreements and address records. Changing a registered office or service address later is possible, but it creates administration and may end mail-handling arrangements.
Tide vs 1st Formations: which should you choose?
Choose Tide for a simple eligible company where price and Tide banking matter most. Its formation route remains difficult to beat on straightforward value, which makes Tide the overall Tide vs 1st Formations winner for that mainstream use case.
Choose 1st Formations when specialist capability matters. Privacy, non-resident support, multiple company types, the first Confirmation Statement and bank choice can easily justify its higher standard package price.
Alternatives
Other formation services to consider
Read the full Tide formation offer and 1st Formations offer, or the Tide formation review and 1st Formations review. You can also see our Tide business banking review.
ANNA Money
£19 Just Register combines low-cost formation with a starter ANNA account and more director flexibility than Tide's linked route. See the Tide vs ANNA Money comparison and the ANNA Money vs 1st Formations comparison.
Companies House direct
£100 online without a formation-agent package.
Solicitor or accountant
Appropriate for bespoke ownership, investment, tax residence or cross-border questions.
FAQs
Tide vs 1st Formations FAQs
Tide is better for a straightforward eligible single-shareholder founder prioritising cost. 1st Formations is better for specialist packages, privacy, non-residents and broader structural needs.
Tide's stand-alone formation is £14.99. 1st Formations Digital is £102.99 including the £100 Companies House fee and first Confirmation Statement filing.
Tide does not currently state that it is included with the £14.99 stand-alone route. Confirm the live inclusions before applying.
It currently includes incorporation, the Companies House fee, identity verification and personal code support, digital documents and filing of the first Confirmation Statement.
Its £1 package is conditional on starting an accounting subscription. It is not a £1 stand-alone formation.
No. Tide's £1 route is linked to its Company Secretary subscription at the current advertised monthly price.
1st Formations has the clearer specialist Privacy package. Tide offers a separate Virtual Office product that may suit some founders.
1st Formations offers a dedicated non-resident package. Tide's route is aimed at UK-based businesses and narrower eligibility.
1st Formations advertises several bank introductions. Each bank makes its own eligibility and approval decision.
No. Formation and banking approval involve separate checks even when presented as one journey.
Both advertise around one working day or 24 hours for standard successful applications, subject to Companies House and provider checks.
1st Formations offers a full accountant-led subscription with Xero. Tide offers accounting tools within its platform. Compare scope, advice, filing responsibility and annual cost.
Yes. Direct online incorporation currently costs £100 and usually completes within 24 hours, subject to successful verification and processing.
Methodology
The Tide vs 1st Formations verdict weights eligibility first, then first-year cost, service depth, privacy, compliance, banking choice and support. Promotions do not determine the result. Checked 1 November 2026. See how we compare.